Forgiveness Is Not a License to Rewrite History — And Law Enforcement Is Not Persecution
By Montgomery Saah, Sr., A Concerned Citizen • Monrovia, Liberia
Former President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf has spoken again, and once again her words demand an answer. In the November 19, 2026 edition of Front Page Africa, she is quoted warning that “peace without unity, inclusion and equal opportunity is not enough.” On its face, that sounds noble. In context, it is not a neutral sermon. It is presented alongside the retrial of former Speaker Fonati Koffa, the detention of former Vice President Jewel Howard-Taylor, and the CDC’s accusation that the Boakai government is “weaponizing justice.” The clear implication is that Liberia’s peace is under threat because the law is being enforced.
That implication must be rejected — firmly, factually, and without apology. Liberia’s peace is not threatened because criminals are being arrested. Liberia’s peace was threatened when criminals were allowed to walk free, when warlords became kingmakers, when financiers of rebellion became presidents, and when impunity was rebranded as reconciliation. What Liberians are witnessing today under President Joseph Nyuma Boakai is not the collapse of the post-war bargain. It is, for the first time in a generation, the honest enforcement of that bargain: no one — not a former Speaker, not a former Vice President, not a former President — is above the law.
And on that point, Madam Sirleaf is the last person who should be lecturing Liberia about peace, unity, and inclusion. Liberians forgave her. They did not forget what she admitted. And forgiveness does not grant her a permanent moral pulpit from which to undermine a government that is finally doing what her own administration failed to do: confront impunity without fear or favor.
- The Record She Cannot Outrun: Madam Sirleaf and the War She Helped Start
Before Madam Sirleaf lectures anyone on peace, Liberia must remember how the war began — and her own admitted role in it.
- Admitted financing: She admitted before Liberia’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) that she helped raise several thousand dollars for then-rebel leader Charles Taylor at the start of the civil war. The TRC described her as a “financier” of Taylor’s armed faction.
- The TRC recommendation: The TRC’s Final Report recommended that Sirleaf be barred from public office for 30 years for her association with warring factions. That was not an opposition smear. That was the verdict of the very commission she herself established in 2006 to “promote national peace, security, unity and reconciliation.”
- The apology: On July 26, 2009, she publicly apologized to Liberia for supporting Charles Taylor. An apology is an admission. You do not apologize for something you did not do.
- The rhetoric: Contemporary reporting at the time noted that she at one point publicly urged Taylor to destroy the Executive Mansion, the seat of President Samuel Doe. Whether one calls that youthful revolutionary zeal or reckless warmongering, it is the opposite of peacemaking.
Let us be blunt: Charles Taylor’s National Patriotic Front of Liberia (NPFL) did not emerge from thin air. It needed money, international legitimacy, political cover, and elite Liberian sponsors who gave a warlord credibility in Washington, Abidjan, and Monrovia. Madam Sirleaf, by her own testimony, was among those early sponsors. She later withdrew support when Taylor forces began killing civilians — a withdrawal that deserves acknowledgement, but does not erase the sponsorship. A person who helps light a fire cannot claim innocence because she later called for water.
This is why her current “peace alarms” ring hollow. The woman who helped finance the rebellion that killed an estimated 250,000 Liberians now presents herself as the guardian of the peace that followed. Liberians were generous enough to forgive her and elect her twice. That generosity was an act of national maturity. It was not a transfer of moral ownership over Liberia’s future. Forgiveness does not mean amnesia. And it certainly does not mean she can weaponize her elder-stateswoman status to delegitimize every government that refuses to govern by her rules.
- What Madam Sirleaf’s 12 Years Actually Produced: Peace Without Justice
Madam Sirleaf led Liberia for 12 years, from 2006 to 2018. She deserves credit for stabilizing the country after war, attracting donors, and keeping the guns silent. But let us tell the whole truth about that stability:
- Justice deferred: The TRC recommendations were largely shelved. No war-crimes court was established under her leadership. The most responsible for atrocities were never prosecuted in Liberia. Reconciliation was reduced to speeches, not accountability.
- Corruption entrenched: Corruption flourished. From the Sable Mining bribery scandal to opaque concessions and a culture of elite impunity, her administration became synonymous with the very exclusion and unequal opportunity she now decries.
- Elite inclusion: The same political class that benefited from war — Taylor loyalists, warlords’ allies, and their families — was absorbed into government rather than held to account. Inclusion, in practice, meant including the powerful, not the victims.
- Unfinished business: By the time she left office, Liberians were not asking for more lectures on unity. They were asking for jobs, roads, schools, hospitals, and a justice system that worked for the poor as well as the powerful.
In other words, Madam Sirleaf’s “peace” was a peace of convenience: keep the elites comfortable, keep the donors happy, keep the victims quiet. It was peace without justice, and peace without justice is only a ceasefire between elections. President Boakai inherited that unfinished peace — and he is now being attacked for trying to finish it.
- The Present Cases Are Not Persecution. They Are Prosecutions.
The Front Page Africa caption lumps together three very different realities to create a false narrative of a crackdown. Each case must be judged on its facts, not on opposition slogans.
- Former Speaker Fonati Koffa — The Capitol Arson Case
Koffa is not being persecuted for being opposition. He is facing trial over the December 2024 fire that gutted the Capitol Building — the very seat of Liberia’s democracy. The charges filed by the Liberia National Police include arson, criminal mischief, reckless endangerment, criminal attempt to commit murder, criminal facilitation, and conspiracy.
On August 27, 2026, the full bench of the Supreme Court of Liberia, led by Chief Justice Yamie Quiqui Gbeisay Sr., ordered a fresh trial after rejecting Koffa’s petition for a writ of prohibition. That is how a constitutional democracy works: courts decide, not presidents. If Koffa is innocent, the courtroom — not press conferences, not party headquarters, not former presidents’ alarms — is where he will prove it.
Burning the Capitol is not opposition politics. It is an attack on the state. No serious democracy would treat it as a mere misunderstanding. Liberia cannot preach that “no one is above the law” and then exempt a former Speaker because his party shouts loudly.
- Former Vice President Jewel Howard-Taylor — The Cocaine Case
Howard-Taylor was arrested on August 19, 2026, at Roberts International Airport in connection with an investigation into the seizure of about four tons of cocaine in Duazon, Margibi County, in July 2026. She was subsequently charged with drug trafficking, money laundering, criminal conspiracy, and related offenses. On October 7, 2026, a Montserrado County grand jury formally indicted her on nine counts tied to an alleged transnational cocaine-trafficking network prosecutors value at US$336 million. Criminal Court “C” denied her motion for bail, ruling that allegations of continued involvement extended into August 2026.
Let that sink in: four tons of cocaine. Hundreds of millions of dollars. A transnational network. This is not a parking ticket. This is not a political disagreement. This is the kind of crime that destroys young Liberians, funds violence, corrupts institutions, and turns a country into a transit hub for cartels.
Her lawyers have raised legitimate concerns about her health — asthma and high blood pressure — and the courts have considered compassionate treatment. That is due process. But due process does not mean impunity because of a former title, a famous ex-husband, or a political party. The law does not ask whether you were Vice President. It asks whether you committed the crime.
And here the irony is devastating: Howard-Taylor is the ex-wife of Charles Taylor — the same warlord Madam Sirleaf once financed. The Taylor network has haunted Liberia for three decades: war, then prison in The Hague for Taylor, now a cocaine indictment for his former wife. If Madam Sirleaf is truly worried about Liberia’s post-war bargain, she should be asking how the Taylor circle kept accumulating power and wealth under the very “peace” she presided over — not shielding its members from accountability today.
- The CDC’s “Weaponized Justice” Claim
The Congress for Democratic Change (CDC) has every right to defend its members. It does not have the right to redefine every arrest as persecution. If arrests were truly political, why do they follow indictments, grand jury findings, police investigations, and court rulings? Why do they involve specific crimes — arson and cocaine — that no reasonable Liberian would excuse?
The opposition’s logic is circular: anyone arrested must be innocent because they are opposition, and any prosecution must be political because the accused is opposition. That is not a legal argument. That is a demand for immunity. Liberia tried immunity for 23 years. It produced more crime, not more peace.
- The Real Threat to Peace Is Impunity, Not Accountability
Sirleaf warns that “peace without unity, inclusion and equal opportunity is not enough.” She is right about the diagnosis — but she has the prescription backwards.
True unity is not achieved by protecting elites from prosecution. True unity is achieved when a market woman in Waterside and a former Vice President face the same law. True inclusion is not achieved by giving war-era networks a permanent seat at the table. True inclusion is achieved by giving victims, youth, and ordinary Liberians a justice system they can trust. True equal opportunity is not achieved by letting drug money and arson go unpunished. It is achieved by clearing the system of those who profit from destroying it.
For 23 years, Liberia has lived with a dangerous bargain: forgive the powerful, forget the victims, and call it peace. That bargain is what is now being tested — not by Boakai, but by those who want it to continue forever. Boakai is testing whether Liberia can move from a peace of impunity to a peace of law.
And Liberians are gravitating toward that real peace. They are tired of a country where the big man never goes to jail, where cocaine flows through our ports, where the Capitol can burn and no one answers. They want a Liberia where the law is not a weapon for the powerful, but a shield for the powerless. That is what Boakai is building, one difficult prosecution at a time.
- A Message to Madam Sirleaf: Respect the Peace You Did Not Finish
Madam Former President, Liberia honors you for your service. Liberia forgave you for your role in the war. Liberia elected you, celebrated you, and gave you a Nobel Peace Prize. No one can take that history away from you.
But honor is not immunity from criticism. Forgiveness is not a gag order on the truth. And elder status is not a veto over a sitting president’s duty to enforce the law.
If you are genuinely concerned about peace, use your voice to:
- 1. Defend due process, not impunity — Urge all accused persons to submit to the courts and prove their innocence with evidence, not press statements.
- 2. Respect the judiciary — Call on the CDC and all parties to respect court rulings, including the Supreme Court’s August 2026 order for a retrial in the Koffa case.
- 3. Stand with victims of drugs and arson — Support the fight against drugs that is killing our children, rather than framing drug prosecutions as political vendettas.
- 4. Tell the whole truth — Acknowledge your own admitted role in financing Taylor’s rebellion — and explain why you believe those who now face serious criminal charges should be exempt from the accountability you yourself escaped.
What you must not do is lend your immense international credibility to a narrative that equates law enforcement with dictatorship. That narrative is dangerous. It tells young Liberians that crime is politics, that courts are enemies, that Liberia cannot be governed by law. It emboldens those who would burn buildings and traffic drugs to claim they are martyrs. It risks the very peace you claim to protect.
Liberia does not need another alarm from those who helped start the fire. Liberia needs steady leadership from those who are putting it out.
Conclusion: Liberia Has Chosen Law Over Fear
Twenty-three years after the guns fell silent, Liberia faces a choice. It can go back to the old bargain — forgive the powerful, forget the victims, and call impunity peace. Or it can embrace a new bargain — forgive the past, but prosecute the present; honor elders, but obey the law; protect opposition rights, but punish opposition crimes.
President Boakai has chosen the second path. He has said no one is above the law, and his government is acting like it. That is not weaponized justice. That is justice, finally, without weapons — without warlords, without financiers, without fear.
Madam Sirleaf helped bring war to Liberia. President Boakai is trying to bring law to Liberia. Liberians know the difference. And they will not let nostalgia for a flawed peace stop them from building a just peace.
The guns have been silent for 23 years. Now let the law speak — clearly, fairly, and for everyone.
Note on Sources and Method: This rebuttal is written from the perspective of the author. Factual claims about the TRC, Sirleaf’s testimony and apology, the Koffa Capitol arson charges and Supreme Court retrial order of August 27, 2026, and the Howard-Taylor arrest of August 19, 2026, Duazon cocaine seizure, and October 7, 2026 grand jury indictment are drawn from contemporaneous Liberian press reporting, including Front Page Africa, The Liberian Observer, and The Liberian Investigator, and from TRC-related reporting. All accused persons are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law; this rebuttal argues that prosecution itself is legitimate and must be allowed to proceed without political interference.





